PAX West 2018 kicked off this weekend in Seattle, and Riot Games was in attendance. The company’s regular weekend-long panel featured an NA LCS semifinals viewing party, cosplay showcases, meet and greets, LCS team giveaways, and an exclusive narrative-building event with Riot’s narrative team.
Unfortunately for Riot, not many fans in the League of Legends community care about any of that, because in the room next to the main event, Riot is hosting how-to presentations and insights into working at the company for women and non-binary people only.
This room, which runs until the end of the event on Monday, was designed to help women and non-binary folks interact with Riot’s own female staffers and learn more about getting into the industry, according to the company’s PAX info page from last week. This room, or rather the concept of this room, has divided the League community down the middle. Either you’re in favor of it or you’re calling it “reverse-sexism.”
To be clear one more time, though, these seminars were held next to the main room and were intended to help females and non-binary people jump into game development. Men weren’t barred from entering the primary Riot panel, and Riot confirmed with Dot Esports that the female and non-binary seminars were livestreamed for all interested parties.
The debate has been raging on since Friday.
To help recruit women into gaming, we held PAX workshops for women and non-binary people. We’re proud of that and stand with Rioters at PAX. Regarding conversations about this, we need to emphasize that no matter how heated a discussion, we expect Rioters to act with respect.
— Riot Games (@riotgames) September 2, 2018
Other people have said it more eloquently than I have, so I'll just say it plainly – giving women and nonbinary folks a place to ask questions at PAX without men is NOT sexism against men. Men have all the advantages and attention EVERYWHERE else at PAX.
— J.T. Vandenbree | #BLM (@TizaTryhards) September 1, 2018
The stuff Riot Games is doing at PAX is really really dumb.
— Karma (@thelykken) September 2, 2018
I feel like the word equality has no meaning sometimes. As soon as it turns into "Hheheh, we'll teach those cis white males for existing 😈"
ITS LITERALLY THE SAME SHIT THEY'RE GOING AGAINST LOL
>Riot is at PAX
— Twitchy (@FishPrison) September 1, 2018
>Might use this time to help save their dying game by talking to fans
>Instead, closes the panel off for 30 minutes and dissallows anyone who isnt female or nonbinary
>Daniel Z Klein responds to the reaction to this by calling everyone 'manbabies'
Good company
The decision to hold this panel in the first place likely stems from the sexist culture within Riot Games revealed by Kotaku’s exposé last month, which Riot has admitted fault for and has since apologized. In Riot’s apology, the company also claimed that it would be taking drastic, immediate, and long-term action to improve things going forward. Without an official confirmation from Riot, we assume this inclusivity panel was a part of those efforts.
Half of the League community was staunchly opposed to the idea of this panel, though, calling it “reverse-sexism” and “archaic” on mediums such as Twitter and Reddit. The other half defends the panel’s inclusivity. Regular, everyday players jumped into the bonfire to voice their opinions, but so did some of the most noteworthy personalities in the space, including Indiana “Froskurinn” Black, Kelsey Moser, Weldon Green, Zack “Rusty” Pye, and many, many more.
I find it, frankly, laughable how so many people have the privlliage to look at a headline like this and say: "keep an open mind and recognize the credible aspects of this story. Then decide." While so many women have lived these experiences daily. Get on the same page already.
— Froskurinn (@Froskurinn) August 7, 2018
RE: PAX sexism discussion
— Kelsey Moser (莫凯西) (@karonmoser) September 1, 2018
I don't oppose and occasionally support career outreaches that target women in gaming.
Events with a career in gaming bent that exclude men reinforce an archaic idea that women cannot coexist with men professionally. It is not the solution.
Twitter is home to the most discussion, albeit usually slightly-hostile discussion, whereas Reddit has been a bit of a witch hunt. Today, two separate satirical threads mocking Riot’s decision made the front page, racking up a total of over 10,000 upvotes.
This year has been fraught with PR nightmare after PR nightmare for Riot, including the failure of Clash, rampant internal sexism, game balance uproar, and most recently, the Worlds broadcast announcement. This particular issue at PAX, however, isn’t so black-and-white, and largely depends on which side of the issue you land on. Riot is unfaltering in its defense of the female and non-binary seminars, and those opposed to the idea have been equally as unfaltering.
One thing is sure, though. Riot promised that it would take immediate action to make women feel safer and more included. And whether you agree with the methods, action was certainly taken.
