It’s World Cup quarterfinal time in Qatar. The second match on the day brings together old rivals as the Netherlands will attempt to deprive Lionel Messi of the chance to win the World Cup for Argentina in what is likely his final opportunity. Messi’s presence might sway most observers into thinking Argentina has the upper hand in this quarterfinal clash, but FIFA 23 might have something to say about that.
We went through the in-game player ratings for both nations to see if one has a clear advantage over the other. We’ve reached a stage in the tournament where that’s becoming more and more unlikely, but you never know how FIFA 23 can surprise you.
We took the starting lineups the Netherlands and Argentina used in their round of 16 victories over the USA and Australia, respectively. Only FUT World Cup Player items are eligible for this comparison. Here’s how the numbers look.
Netherlands FIFA 23 World Cup player ratings
- GK: Andries Noppert – 75 OVR
- RB: Denzel Dumphries – 83 OVR
- CB: Virgil Van Dijk – 90 OVR
- CB: Jurriën Timber – 81 OVR
- CB: Nathan Aké – 80 OVR
- LB: Daley Blind – 81 OVR
- CM: Marten de Roon – 81 OVR
- CM: Frenkie de Jong – 87 OVR
- CAM: Davy Klaassen – 81 OVR
- ST: Memphis Depay – 85 OVR
- ST: Cody Gakpo – 84 OVR
Argentina FIFA 23 World Cup player ratings
- GK: Emiliano Martínez – 84 OVR
- RB: Nahuel Molina – 80 OVR
- CB: Cristian Romero – 84 OVR
- CB: Nicolás Otamendi – 82 OVR
- LB: Marcos Acuña – 85 OVR
- CM: Rodrigo De Paul – 84 OVR
- CM: Enzo Fernandez – 78 OVR
- CM: Alexis Mac Allister – 79 OVR
- RW: Lionel Messi – 91 OVR
- LW: Alejandro Gómez – 84 OVR
- ST: Julián Alvarez – 78 OVR
This is one of the more curious FIFA 23 comparisons we’ve done this World Cup. While we can say that the Netherlands and Argentina are relatively equal in quality, these squads’ strengths and weaknesses are night and day. Argentina has a huge advantage at goalkeeper and on the wings, while the Netherlands has much better strikers and doesn’t use wingers at all, instead going to their strong full-backs for width.
FIFA 23 says the crucial battle in central midfield will be won by the Dutch. With the above factors canceling each other out, FIFA 23 predicts that the trio of de Roon, de Jong, and Klaassen will lead to a European triumph and an end to Leo Messi’s World Cup dream. When you have a player of the highest standard like Messi, though, numbers don’t always tell the full story.
